The Chopped Cheese sandwich, a staple of New York City bodegas, has made its way to Westchester County, attracting foodies who crave late-night and hangover-friendly gastronomy. If you’re wondering where to find the best Chopped Cheese in Westchester, you’ve come to the right place.
Westchester Woman will tell you everything you need to know about the history of this iconic sandwich, what makes it so damn delicious, and where to get a meaty masterpiece in Westchester.
The History of Chopped Cheese: A Culinary Mystery
While the origins of the Chopped Cheese sandwich aren’t totally solid, the sandwich is believed to have been inspired by various dishes across Arabic cuisines, with the dagha yamneeya being a key influence. Haji’s in Spanish Harlem is often credited with the creation of the sandwich, but even its staff members admit that its former chef likely borrowed elements from Middle Eastern dishes and adapted them using readily available ingredients.
The Chopped Cheese has since become an everyman meal that’s gained popularity in New York City bodegas. Its rise to fame has been mostly through word-of-mouth, making it an underground sensation that many New Yorkers are still discovering.
Deconstructing the Chopped Cheese Sandwich: What’s Inside?
At its core, a Chopped Cheese consists of hamburger patty meat that is chopped up and cooked on a griddle, then mixed with cheese (typically American). The meat and cheese mixture is then placed onto a long wedge or roll and topped with a blend of lettuce, tomato, and onion. Some serve it with mayo, ketchup, and/or mustard, and other toppings like peppers or pickles.
Though it’s often compared to a Philly cheesesteak, the Chopped Cheese is undeniably a unique creation, making it a must-try for anyone seeking an authentic taste of New York City culture.
Best Chopped Cheese in Westchester: Top Spots to Satisfy Your Cravings
With the Chopped Cheese Westchester scene growing, we’ve compiled a list of the best places to get your hands on one if you can’t trek to New York City. Visit these Chopped Cheese restaurants and experience this delicious New York City culinary phenomenon for yourself here in Westchester County, NY.
The Chipper Truck & Cafe
Address: 651 McLean Ave, Yonkers
The Chipper Truck & Cafe have an extensive menu of delicious comfort food that is offered late into the night and early morning, including a Chopped Cheese. They allow you to add all kinds of toppings like their famous “pink sauce,” garlic mayo, bacon, or hot sauce.
Main Street Deli & Grocery
Address: 101 Main St, Tuckahoe
Main Street Deli & Grocery in Tuckahoe is another excellent location to grab a Chopped Cheese sandwich. Known for its fresh ingredients and hefty portions, this deli is sure to provide you with a memorable Chopped Cheese experience.
North River Deli a.k.a. “Deli Mart”
Address: 671 North Ave, New Rochelle
Located near Iona College, North River Deli is a classic bodega-style deli that’s open late to cater to students looking for a tasty late-night meal. Their Chopped Cheese sandwich is one of the best ways to recover after a weekend of partying or studying.
Cross County Deli & Grocery
Address: 838 McLean Ave, Yonkers
Located in Yonkers, Cross County Deli & Grocery offers a super scrumptious Chopped Cheese sandwich that’s sure to satisfy your cravings. They also serve a truly mouth-watering selection of other sandwiches and deli items.
Riverdale Ave Deli
Address: 352 Riverdale Ave, Yonkers
Just a few blocks south of Riverdale Deli & Grocery, Riverdale Ave Deli serves another top-tier Chopped Cheese. Their version sticks to the classic recipe, featuring burger, cheddar, lettuce, and tomatoes with ketchup and mayo. Choose between a roll for $4.50 or a full hero for $7.
Anthony Deli Mini Market
Address: 183 Martine Ave #3304, White Plains
Anthony’s Deli in White Plains offers a tangy twist on their Chopped Cheese with sweet peppers. They list ketchup as an optional topping, which may spark some debate among Chopped Cheese enthusiasts. Regardless of your topping preferences, their sandwich is a must-try.
Riverdale Deli & Grocery
Address: 92 Ludlow St, Yonkers
Riverdale Deli & Grocery in Yonkers not only offers the coveted Chopped Cheese sandwich, but it’s also on their regular menu. For just $4.50, you can grab the standard version, or splurge an extra $2 for the deluxe, which comes with fries.
Sugar Bowl Deli
Address: 210 Gramatan Ave, Mt Vernon
Sugar Bowl Deli in Mt Vernon features an entire section of their menu called the “ChoppedCheese Factory.” Choose between a four-ounce “classic” or an eight-ounce “hero,” or try one of their more adventurous creations. The Patron combines eight ounces of meat with crispy bacon, BBQ sauce, green peppers, and all the usual suspects, while the Texas adds two eggs to the classic. For a spicy twist, go for the Tony Style, which substitutes chipotle mayo for added zing.
Corner Deli & Grocery
Address: 500 Mamaroneck Ave, Harrison
Corner Deli & Grocery in Harrison is known for its friendly service and delicious sandwiches, with their Chopped Cheese being a standout option. This spot is perfect for anyone who wants to try a tasty Chopped Cheese sandwich made with care and attention to detail.
Eastchester Super Deli
Address: 230 Main St, Eastchester
Located across from Eastchester Inn, Eastchester Super Deli offers a solid Chopped Cheese sandwich that can be found right at the top of their menu. Just order the No. 1 and prepare to indulge in this delicious creation.
4 Bros Pizza
Address: 23 S Division St, New Rochelle
4 Bros Pizza in New Rochelle offers 100% New York-certified Chopped Cheese that comes with bell pepper and 4 Bros Fancy Sauce for added flavor. Made on an extra-large, house-made burger roll, this sandwich may be part of their “Secret Instagram Menu,” but one phone call and you can ask if they’ll make you one. They do have Chopped Cheese Fries on their menu.
Best Chopped Cheese Near Me: How to Find More Great Spots
As the Chopped Cheese Westchester scene continues to expand, more and more local bodegas and delis are adding this delicious sandwich to their menus. To find the best Chopped Cheese near you, keep an eye out for bodegas and delis in your area that serve this iconic New York City staple. Most establishments are happy to make a Chopped Cheese sandwich for you, even if it’s not listed on their menu.
In Conclusion: Embrace the Chopped Cheese Westchester Experience
The Chopped Cheese sandwich is a true culinary gem that has made its way from the streets of New York City to the heart of Westchester County. With its rich history, savory flavor profile, and growing popularity, it’s a must-try for any food enthusiast. Check out the Chopped Cheese restaurants mentioned in this guide or discover new spots on your own to experience the delicious flavors of this iconic sandwich. So go ahead and indulge in the best Chopped Cheese Westchester has to offer, and remember to share your favorite finds with fellow foodies.